
SECOND OPINION
AN INDEPENDENT, STRUCTURED REVIEW
A formal second-opinion service with Dr Mustafa Alttahir for complex orthopaedic problems — hip, knee, ankle, foot and limb. For patients facing a major operation, considering revision surgery, recovering from a failed previous operation, or who have been told that nothing more can be done.
Sometimes the answer is the same as the one you’ve already been given. Sometimes it isn’t. Either way, the value is in understanding it properly.
AT A GLANCE
Consultation — in person, or by telehealth where eligible — with a written report
Typically 7–14 days from imaging review
X-rays, often CT, sometimes MRI
Clear, in your own words, with options
WHO IT’S FOR
01
BEFORE
You’ve been told you need surgery
You want to be sure it’s the right operation, at the right time, with the right expectations — before you commit.
• Recommended hip or knee replacement
• Choosing between fusion and ankle replacement
• Partial vs total knee replacement
• Considering robotic vs conventional
• Younger patient, uncertain about timing
02
AFTER
A previous surgery hasn’t worked
Pain has returned, function is poor, or imaging shows a problem. You want an independent assessment of what’s gone wrong — and the realistic options.
REVISION & FAILED SURGERY
• Failed primary hip or knee replacement
• Failed ankle replacement or fusion
• Non-union or malunion after fracture
• Persistent pain after previous surgery
• Suspected infection of an implant
03
BEYOND
You’ve been told nothing more can be done
Sometimes that’s still the right answer. Sometimes custom implants, osseointegration or modern reconstruction open an option that wasn’t on the table.
COMPLEX LIMB RECONSTRUCTION
• Considered too complex for standard implants
• Severe bone loss or deformity
• Multiple failed previous surgeries
• Amputation recommended
• Told that no further surgery is possible
SETTING EXPECTATIONS
WHAT YOU GET
✓ An independent review of your case
✓ Detailed assessment of all imaging and prior operative reports
✓ Honest opinion on whether previous advice is sound
✓ Clear explanation of the realistic options
✓ A written summary you can keep and share
✓ An honest answer — even if it’s the same one you’ve heard
WHAT THIS ISN’T
✕ A guarantee that a different answer exists
✕ An automatic recommendation to operate
✕ Criticism of your previous surgeon
✕ A commitment to ongoing care if not appropriate
✕ A substitute for emergency assessment
✕ Free of cost (see fee section below)
THE PROCESS
A structured review process, from first contact to written summary.
01
Submit your details
Through the form below or by phone. You will be asked for a brief outline of the problem, prior operations, and the names of doctors who have seen you.
02
Gather imaging and records
The rooms guide you through what to send: recent X-rays, CT, MRI, operative reports, clinic letters and a GP referral. Imaging can usually be transferred electronically.
03
The case is reviewed
Imaging is reviewed in detail. For complex deformity or revision arthroplasty, 3D reconstruction and CAD analysis may be performed before a recommendation is made.
04
In-person or telehealth consultation
A structured consultation walks through the findings, the diagnosis, and the realistic options. Imaging is shown on screen with explanations in plain language.
05
Written summary
A written report follows the consultation — for you, your GP, your treating specialist or your health fund. Plain language, structured, on letterhead.
06
Whatever comes next is your choice
If surgery is appropriate and you wish to proceed under Dr Alttahir’s care, that pathway is available. If you choose to return to your original surgeon with the report, that’s equally welcomed.
WHAT TO SEND
A second opinion is only as good as the information it is based on. Where records or imaging are missing, the rooms can usually request them on your behalf — but bringing what you have speeds things up.
Imaging from any Australian radiology practice can usually be requested electronically with your permission. The rooms can help arrange this if needed.
ESSENTIAL
GP or specialist referral (for the Medicare rebate)
Recent X-rays of the affected area
A summary of the timeline of the problem
Names of doctors who have seen you
A list of your current medications
HELPFUL IF AVAILABLE
CT scan with metal-artefact reduction (for implants)
MRI scans
All prior operative reports
Implant brand, model and size if known
Blood tests (CRP, ESR if infection a concern)
Recent clinic letters from specialists
WHAT COMES BACK
A structured written report typically follows within 7–14 days of the imaging review and consultation. It may confirm the original advice, suggest another path, or explain why no further surgery is the safest option — whichever is true.
COST & TIME
Initial consultation
60 minutes
In person, or by telehealth for interstate and international patients. It is booked as a long consultation, so the fee is higher than a standard appointment. A Medicare rebate applies where you hold a current GP or specialist referral; the rooms confirm the fee in writing before the appointment.
Imaging review & planning
Quoted separately
Review of all imaging, prior operative reports and, where appropriate, 3D reconstruction or CAD analysis — quoted separately and confirmed in writing before the appointment. Any new imaging is billed by the radiology practice.
Written report
Within 7–14 days
A structured written report follows the consultation and is included in the fee. A custom report beyond the standard consultation report is quoted separately — confirmed before any work begins. This page does not constitute a fee quotation.
WHAT THE CONSULTATION IS LIKE
No script. What a structured second-opinion consultation actually involves, in the order it happens.
Time for your questions is built into the consultation.
01
You’ll be asked to tell your story
Bring a brief written timeline if it helps — the timing matters as much as the imaging.
02
Imaging will be reviewed with you
X-rays, CT and MRI shown on screen with the relevant findings explained in plain language.
03
The diagnosis will be explained
Including whether the previous diagnosis is correct, partially correct, or whether something else is going on.
04
Realistic options will be discussed
Surgical and non-surgical. Each option’s likely outcome and risks discussed honestly — even if it means recommending no further surgery.
05
You’ll be told if it’s the same answer
Sometimes a second opinion confirms exactly what you were told elsewhere. That’s a useful answer, not a wasted appointment.
06
Time for your questions
The consultation includes structured time for your questions. Bringing a written list helps make sure nothing is forgotten.
COMMON QUESTIONS
RELATED
Revision joint replacement
Failed or painful hip, knee and ankle replacements — signs, causes and reconstruction options.
3D planning
CT-based planning and custom 3D-printed implants for cases where standard implants are not enough.
Limb reconstruction
Limb deformity correction, limb lengthening, non-union surgery and osseointegration.
About Dr Alttahir
Training, fellowships, and the approach behind the practice — who is giving the opinion.
BEGIN
Send the key details and the rooms will respond with the next steps for imaging transfer, consultation format and timing.
Request a review
This page describes a second-opinion consultation service and is not a substitute for individual medical advice or emergency assessment. A second opinion does not guarantee a different recommendation or outcome. Medico-legal reports are a separate service. Advertising on this site complies with the AHPRA Guidelines for advertising a regulated health service.