
YOUNG PATIENT ARTHRITIS · OSTEOTOMY · CARTILAGE RESTORATION
ALIGNMENT MEASURED ON STANDING FILMS · CARTILAGE MAPPED ON MRI · EVERY OSTEOTOMY PLANNED IN 3D · PATIENT-SPECIFIC GUIDES
AT A GLANCE
The whole page in one minute — the detail follows below.
WHO THIS IS FOR
Knee or ankle arthritis, cartilage damage or meniscal loss in a patient in their 20s to 50s — often after an injury, often with a bowed, knock-kneed or tilted limb — who has been told a replacement is the only option.
HOW YOU ARE ASSESSED
Examination standing and walking, EOS or long-leg alignment films of both legs, an MRI to map the cartilage, a weight-bearing CT for the ankle, and a 3D model to plan exactly where the correction goes.
THE OPTIONS
Non-operative care first; high tibial or distal femoral osteotomy to shift load off a worn compartment; anteromedialisation tubercle osteotomy and distal femoral osteotomy to offload the kneecap; supramalleolar osteotomy for the ankle; osteochondral allograft transplant for a focal defect in selected cases.
THE COMMITMENT
Bone must heal: protected weight-bearing on crutches for about six weeks after an osteotomy — six to twelve weeks non-weight-bearing after a cartilage transplant — a brace or boot depending on the operation, union confirmed on X-ray before full loading, and six to twelve months to the final result.
NEXT STEP
Call the rooms on (02) 8882 9011 or (02) 9602 1113. A GP referral is needed for the Medicare rebate; fees are discussed with you first and confirmed in writing once surgery is booked.
THE APPROACH
A knee or ankle that wears out at 35 rarely does so by chance. Most have a reason — a limb that loads one side of the joint, a torn ligament that was never stabilised, a fracture that healed a few degrees out, a patch of cartilage knocked off in a tackle. Replace the joint and the reason remains. Correct the reason and the joint can often be kept.
None of this means a younger patient should never have a replacement. It means the question is asked properly first — and, in this practice, the realignment operations that answer it are routine rather than rare.
THE WORKUP
Every patient is measured the same way. Standing films show where the body weight actually travels through the knee and ankle; an MRI shows what cartilage remains; a CT reconstructed in three dimensions shows the deformity an X-ray only hints at. The decision to operate — and where to cut — is made from the measurements, not the impression.
01
Mechanical axis
Where the line from the hip to the ankle crosses the knee, on EOS or long-leg standing films. Through the worn compartment means the alignment is driving the wear.
02
Joint-line angles
The angle of the tibial and femoral joint surfaces decides which bone is deformed — and therefore whether the osteotomy belongs below the knee, above it, or both.
03
Ankle tilt
On weight-bearing ankle films and CT: how far the talus tilts in the mortise and where the joint surface slopes. Asymmetric wear with a tilt is what a supramalleolar osteotomy corrects.
04
Cartilage map
MRI grades the cartilage in each compartment and measures any focal defect — depth, size and location decide between offloading, transplant, or both.
05
Rotation and stability
CT torsional profile where the limb is rotated, and examination for ligament laxity — because a knee or ankle that is unstable keeps wearing however straight it is.
THREE-DIMENSIONAL MODELLING
Dr Alttahir reconstructs the CT in three dimensions, places the osteotomy on the model, and opens or closes the wedge in software until the weight-bearing line sits where it should. For almost every patient that plan is then printed as a patient-specific cutting guide, so the correction made in theatre is the one that was planned.
Alongside the CT: EOS or long-leg films for the axis, MRI for the cartilage and menisci, and weight-bearing CT at Macquarie for the ankle, where the tilt only shows under load.

PATIENT-SPECIFIC GUIDE · PRINTED FROM THE PLAN
WHAT DRIVES IT
Rarely just one, and often several at once. Each is looked for in every patient, because the operation has to match the cause rather than the symptom.
01
Varus alignment
A BOW-LEGGED KNEE
The weight-bearing line runs through the inner compartment, which wears first. Often the leg was always slightly bowed; sometimes a fracture or a meniscectomy tipped it.
HIGH TIBIAL OSTEOTOMY
02
Valgus alignment
A KNOCK-KNEED KNEE
The line runs through the outer compartment, which wears first and pulls the kneecap outward with it.
DISTAL FEMORAL OSTEOTOMY
03
Patellofemoral overload
A KNEECAP LOADED ON ONE SIDE
Years of maltracking wear the cartilage on the outer and lower facet of the kneecap and the groove it runs in, long before the rest of the knee is involved.
ANTEROMEDIALISATION TUBERCLE OSTEOTOMY · DFO WHERE VALGUS DRIVES IT
04
Ankle tilt after injury
A JOINT THAT NO LONGER SITS SQUARE
After an ankle fracture or years of sprains the talus tilts in the mortise, loading one side of the joint and sparing the other — asymmetric arthritis in an otherwise young ankle.
SUPRAMALLEOLAR OSTEOTOMY
05
A focal cartilage defect
A HOLE IN THE SURFACE, THE REST INTACT
A piece of cartilage and underlying bone sheared off by an injury, or lost to osteochondritis dissecans or osteonecrosis — in the knee or the talus.
OSTEOCHONDRAL ALLOGRAFT TRANSPLANT · SELECTED CASES
06
Meniscal loss
THE SHOCK ABSORBER GONE
A knee that has lost most of a meniscus loads that compartment harder; in a limb that already leans that way the wear accelerates.
OFFLOADING OSTEOTOMY · MENISCAL OPTIONS ASSESSED
07
Ligament instability
A JOINT THAT SHIFTS
An ACL-deficient knee or a chronically unstable ankle wears because it moves abnormally with every step — straightening the limb alone will not stop it.
LIGAMENT RECONSTRUCTION · COMBINED WITH REALIGNMENT
08
Rotational malalignment
A LIMB TWISTED, NOT BENT
Excess femoral or tibial torsion loads the kneecap and the knee compartments in ways a standard X-ray misses; it is measured on CT in every patient.
DEROTATION OSTEOTOMY
09
Multilevel deformity
MORE THAN ONE OF THE ABOVE
Most young patients with established wear have two or three of these — a bowed tibia, a lost meniscus, a loose ligament — and correcting one without the others gives a partial result.
MULTILEVEL CORRECTION · COMBINED OR STAGED
TREATMENT
BONE — KNEE · VARUS
01
FOR THE BOW-LEGGED KNEE
The tibia is cut just below the knee and opened on the inner side by a measured number of degrees, shifting the weight-bearing line out of the worn inner compartment and into the healthy outer one. Fixed with a locking plate; the wedge fills in with new bone.
USED WHEN
Varus alignment with inner-compartment wear
Meniscal loss in a bowed knee
A cartilage procedure that needs the load taken off to survive
BONE — KNEE · VALGUS
02
FOR THE KNOCK-KNEED KNEE
The femur is cut just above the knee and realigned so the weight-bearing line runs through the centre of the joint, then fixed with a plate. The same operation that corrects a valgus kneecap problem corrects valgus wear of the outer compartment.
USED WHEN
Valgus alignment with outer-compartment wear
Lateral patellofemoral overload driven by valgus
Combined with a cartilage or meniscal procedure
BONE — KNEECAP
03
OFFLOADING THE KNEECAP
The bony attachment of the patellar tendon is cut and moved forward and inward on an oblique plane, lifting the kneecap away from its groove and shifting its load off the worn outer and lower facet onto healthier cartilage.
USED WHEN
Patellofemoral arthritis from long-standing maltracking
Lateral and distal cartilage loss on the kneecap
Often with a distal femoral osteotomy where valgus drives the tracking
BONE — ANKLE
04
REALIGNING THE ANKLE ABOVE THE JOINT
The tibia is cut just above the ankle and opened or closed by the planned angle so the talus sits square in the mortise again and the load moves onto the preserved half of the joint. Fixed with a plate; the ankle joint itself is untouched.
USED WHEN
Asymmetric ankle arthritis after a fracture or instability
Varus or valgus tilt with half the joint still healthy
Correcting deformity before a later ankle replacement
WITH ALMOST EVERY CASE · AND WHERE THE PATTERN CALLS FOR IT
Osteochondral allograft transplant
A size-matched plug of donor cartilage and bone replaces a focal defect in the knee or the talus — in selected cases, where the defect is contained and the rest of the joint is sound. Dr Alttahir uses fresh donor grafts preserved by the MOPS method, which keeps the graft’s cartilage cells alive until it is implanted. A fresh graft has to be sourced and approved for each patient, which the rooms arrange.
Arthroscopy and cartilage assessment
With almost every case: the joint surfaces are inspected, the menisci and loose fragments dealt with, and the plan confirmed before the bone is cut.
Ligament reconstruction
Where an ACL-deficient knee or an unstable ankle is part of the wear, stabilisation is combined with the realignment — in one operation or in stages.
Non-operative care first
Weight, strengthening, an unloader brace and, where appropriate, injections — tried first, and often enough on their own in the early stages.
IN SUMMARY
The right operation, not the usual one.
Most young patients with wear need the load moved before anything else; some need the surface restored as well. Both are planned together on the same model, and both leave a joint replacement available later — the reverse is not true.
When preservation is no longer an option
Where the wear crosses the whole joint, where the bone is too poor or the deformity too large for an osteotomy, or where inflammatory arthritis is the cause, a replacement is the honest recommendation — robotic knee replacement or ankle replacement, planned the same way.
When it is the right answer
Bone-on-bone wear across the whole joint, not one compartment
Inflammatory arthritis, where realignment does not address the cause
Deformity or bone quality beyond what an osteotomy can correct
A patient whose goals suit a replacement better than months of protected healing
Registry data show replacements in younger patients are revised more often than in older ones — about one in six total knee replacements in patients under 55 has been revised at twenty years — and every revision costs bone
A replaced joint has limits — impact sport and kneeling are generally discouraged
An osteotomy keeps the native joint and leaves replacement available later; a replacement cannot be undone
Patient selection matters more here than for almost any other decision in the knee or ankle
The same principle applies here as everywhere on this page: the operation is chosen for the individual joint, not by the patient’s age alone.
SOURCE: AOANJRR ANNUAL REPORT 2026 — REVISION BY AGE AT SURGERY
SIGNATURE CAPABILITY
An osteotomy is only as good as its angle. The correction is measured in single degrees and millimetres: too little and the load stays on the worn side, too much and it overloads the healthy one.
Dr Alttahir plans every osteotomy on a three-dimensional reconstruction of the patient’s own CT and, for almost every correction, designs a patient-specific cutting guide that is 3D-printed before surgery. In his hands, a guide makes the operation quicker, more accurate and more controlled, with fewer X-rays taken in theatre. Published studies support the gain in accuracy. The planning CT involves a small dose of radiation.
This is the same planning used for custom implants and complex deformity on the 3D planning page. Here it is applied to routine joint preservation — because a few degrees’ error matters more in a 35-year-old’s knee than almost anywhere else.
The exceptions are few — a simple correction in good bone where a guide adds nothing — and there the osteotomy is cut freehand against the plan and checked with fluoroscopy on the table. The decision is made case by case.
WHY PRECISION MATTERS
A few degrees’ error moves the load back onto the worn side — or onto the healthy one
The hinge position decides whether the leg lengthens, shortens or rotates as it straightens
Multilevel corrections compound small errors into large ones
The result is set on the table; it cannot be adjusted afterwards without another operation
HOW IT IS PLANNED
01
Measure the limb
EOS or long-leg films for the axis, CT reconstructed in three dimensions, MRI for the cartilage — every measurement taken the same way, every time.
02
Place the correction
The osteotomy is positioned and opened or closed in software until the weight-bearing line sits where it should — and the knee and ankle are checked together, not one at a time.
03
Print the guide
A patient-specific cutting guide is designed from the model, 3D-printed and sterilised, with the cutting slot and hinge pin set to the plan.
04
Cut, fix and check
The guide seats on the bone, the cut is made through it, the wedge is opened to the planned angle and fixed with a locking plate — then confirmed with fluoroscopy before closing.
THE HONEST POSITION
The guide makes the correction accurate; it does not make the bone unite faster. An osteotomy is still a cut through a weight-bearing bone, with weeks on crutches and months to full strength. What precision buys is confidence that those months are spent healing in the right position.
THE ANKLE
Ankle arthritis in a young adult is almost always post-traumatic — a fracture that healed with the joint a few degrees off square, or years of sprains that left the talus tilting in the mortise. The wear is asymmetric: one half of the joint is worn, the other half is often still good. That asymmetry is what makes an osteotomy possible.
Supramalleolar osteotomy
The tibia is cut above the ankle and the joint surface tilted back to square, so the load moves onto the preserved cartilage. Fixed with a plate; non-weight-bearing in a boot for six weeks while it unites.
Weight-bearing CT at Macquarie
The CT HiRise at Macquarie Medical Imaging scans the ankle under load, which is the only way to see in three dimensions where the talus sits when standing — a lying CT understates the tilt.
Instability and the foot are corrected with it
Where the lateral ligaments are loose or the heel is out of line, they are repaired or realigned at the same time — an ankle that keeps rolling will wear again however square the joint sits.
Fusion and replacement stay available
An osteotomy spends nothing: if the ankle wears through later, an ankle replacement or fusion is still possible, and often easier in a limb that has already been straightened.
Ankle replacement and fusion are described on their own page. For the young ankle with half its cartilage left, the osteotomy comes first.
THE OPERATION
Operating time varies with what is being corrected — around an hour to ninety minutes for a single osteotomy, longer for combined bone and cartilage procedures. Most patients stay one to two nights.
ANAESTHESIA
A femoral or adductor canal block for the knee, a popliteal or ankle block for the ankle, combined with a general anaesthetic — so the first night is comfortable.
ARTHROSCOPY & ASSESSMENT
The joint surfaces are inspected, the cartilage graded against the MRI, menisci and loose fragments dealt with, and any cartilage procedure prepared.
APPROACH
The osteotomy site is exposed through a short incision — below the knee, above it, above the ankle or at the tubercle — protecting the nerves and vessels behind the bone.
THE OSTEOTOMY
The patient-specific guide seats on the bone, the cut is made through it and the wedge is opened or closed to the planned angle — checked against the plan with fluoroscopy.
FIXATION
A locking plate holds the correction; an opening wedge is filled with bone graft or substitute where the gap is large. A cartilage transplant, where planned, is fitted now.
CLOSURE
Wounds are closed in layers. The knee goes into a brace or the ankle into a boot, and the weight-bearing plan is set before you leave theatre.
RECOVERY
Every operation on this page cuts bone or transplants it, so every recovery has the same shape: protected loading while it unites, then a graded return. The details differ by procedure.
HIGH TIBIAL OR DISTAL FEMORAL OSTEOTOMY
The cut bone must unite before it takes full load. Crutches for the first six weeks, then progression as the X-rays allow; most patients are walking unaided by three months and reach their best at six to twelve.
TYPICALLY
Half weight-bearing on crutches for six weeks in good bone; about a fifth in lower-quality bone or a large correction
Range of motion from the first days; physiotherapy from the first fortnight
X-rays confirm union before full loading, impact and sport
ANTEROMEDIALISATION TUBERCLE OSTEOTOMY
The moved tubercle must unite before it can take the full pull of the quadriceps, so the first six weeks protect it.
TYPICALLY
Weight-bearing as tolerated from the first days
Range-of-motion brace locked between 0 and 45 degrees of flexion for six weeks
X-rays confirm union before full loading and sport
SUPRAMALLEOLAR OSTEOTOMY
The tibia is cut above the ankle and fixed with a plate; the ankle rests in a boot while the osteotomy unites, then is loaded progressively.
TYPICALLY
Non-weight-bearing in a boot, on crutches, for six weeks
Wound check at two weeks; physiotherapy for ankle movement out of the boot
Full weight-bearing once union shows on X-ray; impact after six months
OSTEOCHONDRAL ALLOGRAFT TRANSPLANT
The donor plug must incorporate into the surrounding bone before it is loaded. Movement is encouraged early; weight is not.
TYPICALLY
Non-weight-bearing on crutches for six to twelve weeks
Early range of motion to nourish the cartilage
No impact for six to twelve months; sport once the graft has incorporated on imaging
TRUE OF ALL OF THEM
Union sets the pace
No amount of enthusiasm speeds a healing osteotomy. The X-rays decide when loading progresses, and smoking slows them.
Swelling lingers
Swelling around a healing osteotomy for three to six months is normal and is not a sign of a problem.
The new alignment takes getting used to
A leg that has been bowed for twenty years feels strange when it is straight. Gait retraining is part of rehabilitation, and the feeling settles.
WHAT TO EXPECT
Realignment reliably moves the load; what it does for pain depends on how much cartilage was left. Dr Alttahir is candid about which patients do best, and about what these operations cannot do.
Pain relief is the usual result, not a guarantee
Most patients with wear confined to one compartment get lasting relief once the load has moved. Where the cartilage is thin everywhere, the benefit is smaller and shorter.
It buys time; it does not stop time
A realigned joint can keep working for many years, but some will wear through eventually and need a replacement. The osteotomy makes that replacement later, not impossible. In the Finnish national registry, about three in four high tibial osteotomies had not needed a knee replacement at ten years (Niinimäki et al., J Bone Joint Surg Br 2012), and well-selected patients in published series do better.
Realignment protects cartilage; it cannot restore it
Taking the load off worn cartilage lets it stop deteriorating; only a transplant adds surface, and only to a contained defect.
Recovery is measured in months
Six weeks on crutches after an osteotomy — six to twelve after a cartilage transplant — and six to twelve months to the final result are the honest figures. Patients who need to be back on their feet in a fortnight should not have an osteotomy.
The leg will look different
A bowed leg straightened, or a knock-knee corrected, is a visible change — welcome to most, unexpected to some. It is shown on the plan before surgery.
Sport is possible, with caveats
Many patients return to running and pivoting sport once the bone has united and strength has returned. After a cartilage transplant there is no impact for six to twelve months, until the graft has incorporated.
Complications happen
The risks common to operations on the lower limb are infection, bleeding, blood clots in the leg or lung, injury to a nerve or blood vessel, stiffness, pain that persists, slow or failed healing where bone is cut, the complications of anaesthesia, and the need for further surgery.
The risks particular to these operations are a crack through the hinge of the osteotomy, too much or too little correction, injury to the vessels behind the knee and compartment syndrome (both rare), a prominent plate that may need removing, and a transplanted graft failing to incorporate.
They are discussed in detail at consent.
COSTS & HEALTH FUNDS
Surgery is a financial decision as well as a medical one. Fees are discussed with you first and take your circumstances into account; once surgery is booked, and before the operation, you receive written informed financial consent with a complete estimate.
This page does not constitute a fee quotation. Costs and health-fund coverage vary by individual circumstance and are confirmed individually in writing before surgery. This page has been written in line with the Ahpra Guidelines for advertising a regulated health service.
FOR REFERRERS
Referrals are welcomed from general practitioners, sports physicians, physiotherapists and colleagues. The patients who benefit most are referred before the wear has crossed the whole joint.
ROUTINE
Knee pain with varus or valgus alignment in a patient under 55
Inner- or outer-compartment wear on X-ray with the other compartment preserved
Anterior knee pain with patellofemoral wear on MRI in a maltracking knee
Ankle pain years after a fracture or recurrent sprains, with tilt on weight-bearing films
A younger patient told a replacement is the only option
COMPLEX
A focal osteochondral defect of the knee or talus
Failed previous osteotomy, cartilage procedure or ligament reconstruction
Combined deformity — rotation plus angulation, or knee plus ankle
Post-traumatic deformity with instability
Osteonecrosis or osteochondritis dissecans in a young adult
Meniscal deficiency after meniscectomy in a malaligned knee
PLEASE INCLUDE
Weight-bearing knee or ankle X-rays, including a skyline view for the knee
EOS or long-leg standing alignment films of both lower limbs
MRI if already performed
Weight-bearing CT of the ankle if already performed — otherwise it is arranged at Macquarie
Injury history and previous operative reports
Injections and bracing already tried
Occupation and sporting demands
What the patient has been told about replacement
Patients are seen with their existing imaging; new films are arranged only where they change the decision.
SYDNEY ADVANCED ORTHOPAEDICS · (02) 8882 9011 · MACQUARIE · NORWEST · EAST SYDNEY
LIMB RECONSTRUCTION SERVICE NSW · (02) 9602 1113 · CAMPBELLTOWN
COMMON QUESTIONS
RELATED
Robotic knee replacement
ROSA robotic-assisted total and partial knee replacement, planned from X-rays.
Limb reconstruction
Limb deformity correction, lengthening, osseointegration.
3D planning & custom implants
Surgeon-led segmentation, patient-specific guides and implants.
Total ankle replacement
For the ankle that has worn through — Infinity, Inbone and a custom 3D-printed talus component.
BEGIN
CALL THE ROOMS
MACQUARIE · NORWEST · EAST SYDNEY
CAMPBELLTOWN
This page provides general information about patellar instability and its surgical treatment and is not a substitute for individual medical advice. Surgery carries risks; outcomes vary between patients. Trochleoplasty is not performed in this practice. Diagrams are schematic and illustrative only. Advertising on this site complies with the AHPRA Guidelines for advertising a regulated health service.