PATELLAR INSTABILITY

TORSIONAL ASSESSMENT · 3D-PLANNED CORRECTION

A kneecap

A kneecap

A kneecap

A kneecap

that won’t

that won’t

that won’t

that won’t

stay put.

stay put.

stay put.

stay put.

Dr Mustafa Alttahir treats patellar dislocation and maltracking in children, adolescents and adults — early, and with the whole limb in view, not just the knee. Every dislocation is measured, every patient is risk-stratified, and where the anatomy says the kneecap will go again, the cause is corrected before the next dislocation damages the joint.

Dr Mustafa Alttahir treats patellar dislocation and maltracking in children, adolescents and adults — early, and with the whole limb in view, not just the knee. Every dislocation is measured, every patient is risk-stratified, and where the anatomy says the kneecap will go again, the cause is corrected before the next dislocation damages the joint.

EVERY DISLOCATION MEASURED · NINE CAUSES CHECKED · MODELLED IN 3D · TIBIAL TUBERCLE, FEMORAL AND DISTAL FEMORAL OSTEOTOMY · MPFL ALLOGRAFT · WHAT DRIVES IT →

LIMB PROFILE · EOS · CT

LIMB PROFILE · EOS · CT

FEMORAL ANTEVERSION

34.5°

34.5°

TRANSMALLEOLAR AXIS

41.0°

41.0°

mLDFA

84.5°

84.5°

MPTA

88.0°

88.0°

TT–TG DISTANCE

21.5 mm

21.5 mm

HKA

3.5° VALGUS

3.5° VALGUS

AT A GLANCE

The whole page in one minute — the detail follows below.

WHO THIS IS FOR

A kneecap that has dislocated — even once — or that tracks badly and hurts: adolescents and young adults most often, and people in their 30s and 40s whose maltracking is wearing the cartilage.

HOW YOU ARE ASSESSED

Examination, X-rays and an MRI, plus a CT measured in 3D for every patient: femoral and tibial torsion, trochlear and patellar shape, patella height, tubercle position, tilt and ligament laxity — nine causes, checked in all.

THE OPTIONS

Physiotherapy and bracing for maltracking without dislocation; MPFL reconstruction with allograft in every patient who has surgery for dislocation; tibial tubercle transfer, femoral derotation or distal femoral osteotomy where the bones are the cause — often more than one.

THE COMMITMENT

MPFL alone: full weight-bearing in a brace. Tubercle osteotomy: weight-bearing as tolerated in a brace for six weeks. Derotation over a nail: weight-bearing as tolerated with crutches for six weeks. Distal femoral osteotomy: partial loading on crutches for twelve weeks. Months to full recovery in every case.

NEXT STEP

Call the rooms on (02) 8882 9011 or (02) 9602 1113. A GP referral is needed for the Medicare rebate; fees are discussed with you first and confirmed in writing once surgery is booked.

THE APPROACH

Treat it early.

Treat it early.

Treat it early.

A first dislocation in an otherwise normal knee often settles with physiotherapy. A dislocation in a knee that has a reason to dislocate — a shallow groove, a high kneecap, a rotated femur or tibia — usually does not, and the next one can bring a fracture of the cartilage surface with it.

A dislocation can knock a piece of cartilage and bone off the kneecap or the thigh bone. An MRI looks for it, and a loose piece is best fixed back or removed within days to weeks, which is why a first dislocation should be assessed promptly.

Dr Mustafa Alttahir assesses every dislocation, including the first, works out why it happened, and says plainly where the risk lies.

WHAT THE ASSESSMENT DECIDES

·

Every dislocation is measured — the nine causes below, on CT, MRI, standing films and examination

·

Every patient is risk-stratified, and the options for their anatomy are discussed with them

·

Where the anatomy carries risk factors, surgery to correct the cause is recommended rather than deferred

·

Maltracking without dislocation starts with physiotherapy and bracing; realignment is advised once the cartilage shows change

·

The decision is the patient’s, made with the risks of both paths explained

WHAT THE ASSESSMENT DECIDES

·

Every dislocation is measured — the nine causes below, on CT, MRI, standing films and examination

·

Every patient is risk-stratified, and the options for their anatomy are discussed with them

·

Where the anatomy carries risk factors, surgery to correct the cause is recommended rather than deferred

·

Maltracking without dislocation starts with physiotherapy and bracing; realignment is advised once the cartilage shows change

·

The decision is the patient’s, made with the risks of both paths explained

WHY EARLY

·

A second dislocation can shear off a piece of the joint surface — an osteochondral fracture that is often not repairable

·

In Dr Alttahir’s experience, the adolescents who return with that injury are the ones whose first dislocation was managed by waiting

·

Chronic maltracking wears the cartilage behind the kneecap; by the 30s and 40s that wear can be established arthritis

·

Realigning the limb while the cartilage is still intact is the aim — it cannot restore cartilage already lost

WHY EARLY

·

A second dislocation can shear off a piece of the joint surface — an osteochondral fracture that is often not repairable

·

In Dr Alttahir’s experience, the adolescents who return with that injury are the ones whose first dislocation was managed by waiting

·

Chronic maltracking wears the cartilage behind the kneecap; by the 30s and 40s that wear can be established arthritis

·

Realigning the limb while the cartilage is still intact is the aim — it cannot restore cartilage already lost

None of this means every dislocation needs an operation. It means every dislocation deserves the analysis, so that the decision to wait is a decision — not a default.

THE WORKUP

Measure the limb, not the kneecap.

Measure the limb, not the kneecap.

Measure the limb, not the kneecap.

Every patient is measured the same way. An MRI shows the torn ligament and the cartilage; it does not show how the femur and tibia are rotated relative to one another. That takes a dedicated torsional CT, read with the hip, knee and ankle together — and every parameter is measured on a 3D model of the limb, not estimated from a report.

A CT involves a small dose of radiation. Dr Alttahir requests it for every patient because rotation of the femur and tibia cannot be measured on X-ray or a standard MRI, and missed rotation is a common reason stabilising surgery fails.

01

Femoral torsion

How far the femoral neck is rotated relative to the knee. Excess anteversion turns the groove inward while the foot points forward.

02

Tibial torsion

How far the ankle is rotated relative to the knee. External torsion pulls the tubercle — and therefore the kneecap — outward.

03

TT–TG distance

The offset between the tibial tubercle and the trochlear groove, measured on CT. A direct measure of how far laterally the kneecap is being pulled.

04

Patellar height

Whether the kneecap sits too high to engage the groove until the knee is already well flexed.

05

Trochlear shape

Whether the groove is normally formed, shallow, flat or convex — assessed on CT and MRI.

THREE-DIMENSIONAL MODELLING

The measurements, assembled into a limb.

The measurements, assembled into a limb.

Dr Alttahir reconstructs every patient’s CT data in three dimensions so that torsion, tubercle position, patellar height and groove shape can be seen together rather than as separate numbers on separate reports. Where correction is planned, the osteotomy and the amount of rotation are designed in software before theatre and measured precisely in theatre as the bone is corrected, with a patient-specific guide printed from the plan.

Alongside the CT: standing long-leg films for knock-knee alignment, MRI for the ligament and the state of the cartilage, and a laxity examination. Rotation is the one deformity that plain X-rays cannot show and clinical examination tends to underestimate — a knee that looks straight from the front can still be rotated substantially.

TT–TG · 3D CT RECONSTRUCTION

TT–TG · 3D CT RECONSTRUCTION

TT–TG · 3D CT RECONSTRUCTION

WHAT DRIVES IT

Nine things that make a kneecap slip.

Nine things that make a kneecap slip.

Nine things that make a kneecap slip.

Rarely just one, and often several at once. Dr Alttahir checks all nine in every patient; the assessment identifies which are present, which is dominant and which need correcting — and the operation is built from that, not from a default.

01

Trochlear or patellar dysplasia

A SHALLOW GROOVE, OR A KNEECAP THAT DOESN’T FIT IT

The groove the kneecap runs in is underdeveloped, or the kneecap itself is misshapen, so there is little to hold it in place. Trochleoplasty — reshaping the groove — is not performed in this practice: severe dysplasia is managed through the other levers on this page, and where trochleoplasty is the right treatment, referral onward is arranged.

ADDRESSED INDIRECTLY

02

Patella alta

A HIGH-RIDING KNEECAP

The kneecap sits above the groove and only engages it once the knee is well bent. In the early range of flexion, where most dislocations happen, there is nothing holding it.

TIBIAL TUBERCLE DISTALISATION

03

Lateralised tibial tubercle

INCREASED TT–TG DISTANCE

The attachment of the patellar tendon sits too far to the outside, so the whole line of pull drags the kneecap laterally with every contraction of the quadriceps. The bony driver most often corrected.

TIBIAL TUBERCLE OSTEOTOMY

04

Femoral anteversion

THE FEMUR ROTATED INWARD

Excess rotation in the femur turns the knee — and the groove — inward while the foot still points forward. The kneecap is left tracking against the outer edge of a groove that has rotated away from it.

FEMORAL DEROTATION OSTEOTOMY

05

External tibial torsion

THE TIBIA ROTATED OUTWARD

The lower leg is rotated outward relative to the knee, carrying the tubercle with it. Combined with femoral anteversion, this is the pattern called miserable malalignment.

TIBIAL DEROTATION OSTEOTOMY

06

Valgus with lateral patellar tilt

KNOCK-KNEE ALIGNMENT

A knock-kneed limb increases the outward pull on the kneecap and tilts it in its groove. Where the valgus sits in the femur, it is corrected there.

DISTAL FEMORAL OSTEOTOMY · GUIDED GROWTH IN CHILDREN

07

MPFL rupture

THE TORN MEDIAL RESTRAINT

The medial patellofemoral ligament is the main soft-tissue check against lateral dislocation and is torn in almost every first episode. It is reconstructed in every dislocation patient — alongside the bony correction, not instead of it.

MPFL RECONSTRUCTION WITH ALLOGRAFT

08

Ligamentous laxity

GENERALISED JOINT HYPERMOBILITY

Loose joints reduce the passive restraint on the kneecap and raise the risk of recurrence. It is scored at the first visit and shapes the plan, though it is not corrected in isolation.

ASSESSED · ADDRESSED IN CONTEXT

09

Multilevel deformity

MORE THAN ONE OF THE ABOVE

Most recurrent dislocators have two or three of these at once — a rotated femur with a lateralised tubercle, or valgus with patella alta. Correcting one and leaving the others is how stabilisations fail.

MULTILEVEL CORRECTION · COMBINED OR STAGED

TREATMENT

Match the operation to the cause.

Match the operation to the cause.

Match the operation to the cause.

The options below are not a sequence every patient passes through. They are levers, ordered here by how often Dr Alttahir uses them, and the assessment determines which ones apply. A patient whose instability is driven by the tubercle or by torsion does not benefit from a ligament reconstruction alone — and a patient with a normal torsional profile does not need an osteotomy.

The options below are not a sequence every patient passes through. They are levers, ordered here by how often Dr Alttahir uses them, and the assessment determines which ones apply. A patient whose instability is driven by the tubercle or by torsion does not benefit from a ligament reconstruction alone — and a patient with a normal torsional profile does not need an osteotomy.

BONE — TUBERCLE

01

Tibial tubercle osteotomy

Tibial tubercle osteotomy

THE MOST COMMON CORRECTION

The bony attachment of the patellar tendon is cut and moved — inward to reduce the lateral pull, downward to bring a high kneecap into the groove, or both — and fixed with screws securely enough to stand on from the start. It is the correction Dr Alttahir performs most often, almost always with an MPFL reconstruction.

USED WHEN

Increased TT–TG distance

Patella alta

Recurrent dislocation with either of the above

BONE — ROTATION

02

Femoral derotation osteotomy

Femoral derotation osteotomy

THE SECOND MOST COMMON

The femur is cut through a small incision and rotated to correct excess anteversion, the rotation measured precisely as it is applied with a patient-specific guide printed from the plan.

Once the growth plates have closed it is fixed with an intramedullary nail, the less traumatic technique and one that can be walked on; in the rare adolescent whose torsion is severe enough to correct before maturity, it is done over a plate that stays clear of the growth plates.

With tibial derotation where the tibia is also rotated, it is the operation that addresses miserable malalignment, described in the next section.

USED WHEN

Femoral anteversion beyond the normal range

Instability that has failed soft-tissue surgery

Anterior knee pain driven by rotation, even without dislocation

BONE — ALIGNMENT

03

Distal femoral osteotomy

Distal femoral osteotomy

THE THIRD MOST COMMON

A knock-kneed femur is cut and realigned just above the knee, then fixed with a plate, so the limb — and the kneecap’s line of pull — comes back to neutral. In children with growth remaining, guided growth with small temporary implants can achieve the same correction without cutting bone.

USED WHEN

Valgus alignment with lateral patellar tilt

Valgus combined with any of the other drivers

Children with growth remaining — as guided growth

SOFT TISSUE

04

MPFL reconstruction

MPFL reconstruction

EVERY DISLOCATION, WITH ALLOGRAFT

The medial patellofemoral ligament is reconstructed in every patient who has dislocated, using an allograft anchored to the kneecap and the femur at a precise point that lets it tension correctly through the range of motion. It is done alongside the bony correction the assessment calls for — on its own only when the torsional and alignment profile is normal.

An allograft is donor tissue supplied by a tissue bank. It is screened and processed under Australian regulation, and using it avoids taking a tendon from your own knee. The risk of passing on an infection is very small. If you would prefer not to receive donor tissue, say so and the alternatives are discussed.

USED WHEN

Every dislocation

Alone, where no bony driver is present

Combined with the bony corrections above

WITH ALMOST EVERY CASE · AND WHERE THE PATTERN CALLS FOR IT

Arthroscopy and lateral release

Arthroscopy is performed with almost every case: the joint surfaces are inspected and loose fragments dealt with. Where the outer retinaculum is tight, it is released so the realigned kneecap sits in its groove.

Multilevel correction

Common, because most recurrent dislocators have more than one driver — the corrections are combined in one operation or staged, planned together from the 3D model.

Tibial derotation osteotomy

Where the tibia, not the femur, carries the rotation — or both do.

Physiotherapy and bracing first

For maltracking without dislocation: quadriceps and hip strengthening, movement retraining and a patella-stabilising brace. Realignment is advised once the cartilage shows change — not before, and not after it is gone.

IN SUMMARY

The right operation, not the usual one.

Most patients with recurrent instability need a combination: an MPFL reconstruction plus one or two bony corrections. In Dr Alttahir’s experience, a knee that dislocates again after a stabilisation has usually had the ligament addressed while the tubercle, the rotation or the alignment was left as it was. Measuring first, and treating what the measurements show, is the whole approach.

When the cartilage is already gone

Patellofemoral replacement — the salvage option.

Patellofemoral replacement — the salvage option.

Years of maltracking wear the cartilage behind the kneecap and in the groove. Once it is gone, stabilising the kneecap stops the dislocations but not the pain. Where the arthritis is confined to the patellofemoral joint and the rest of the knee is healthy, the worn surfaces can be resurfaced with a small implant — replacing only the front compartment and leaving the rest of the knee intact.

Why it suits these knees

The implant re-creates a groove that dysplasia never formed

The cruciate ligaments and the rest of the knee are preserved

Recovery is quicker than total knee replacement

It can be converted to a total knee replacement later if needed

The honest trade-offs

Pooled data from national joint registries put revision after patellofemoral replacement at roughly 18% by ten years — about three times the rate after total knee replacement — mostly from arthritis progressing elsewhere in the knee.

It resurfaces the damage — it does not correct malalignment, so tubercle or rotational correction is often combined with it

Not suitable where the other compartments are already worn

Patient selection matters more than for almost any other knee implant

The same principle applies here as everywhere on this page: a patellofemoral replacement placed into a maltracking limb will fail the way the native kneecap did. The torsional profile and tubercle position are assessed first, and corrected first or at the same operation.

SOURCE: VELLA-BALDACCHINO ET AL., J ORTHOP SURG RES 2025 — POOLED NATIONAL JOINT REGISTRIES

SIGNATURE CAPABILITY

Miserable malalignment.

Miserable malalignment.

Miserable malalignment.

Miserable malalignment is the combination of a femur rotated inward and a tibia rotated outward. The knee is caught between them, and the kneecap pays for it.

The name is older than the understanding. It describes a limb in which excess femoral anteversion and excess external tibial torsion cancel each other out at the foot — the foot points forward, the leg looks straight — while the knee between them is rotated inward, the kneecap tracks against the outer edge of its groove, and the patient has anterior knee pain, instability, or both, often since adolescence.

The name is older than the understanding. It describes a limb in which excess femoral anteversion and excess external tibial torsion cancel each other out at the foot — the foot points forward, the leg looks straight — while the knee between them is rotated inward, the kneecap tracks against the outer edge of its groove, and the patient has anterior knee pain, instability, or both, often since adolescence.

The name is older than the understanding. It describes a limb in which excess femoral anteversion and excess external tibial torsion cancel each other out at the foot — the foot points forward, the leg looks straight — while the knee between them is rotated inward, the kneecap tracks against the outer edge of its groove, and the patient has anterior knee pain, instability, or both, often since adolescence.

Because the foot points forward and the X-rays look normal, it is easy to miss on a standard knee workup. The torsional profile on CT is what reveals it.

Correction means cutting and rotating the femur, the tibia, or both. Each osteotomy is planned in three dimensions from the CT, the amount of rotation is calculated in software and then measured precisely in theatre as it is applied with a patient-specific guide printed from the plan. It is a substantial operation — but for the right patient it addresses the actual cause rather than its consequences.

THE PATTERN

Femur rotated inward — the kneecap and groove turn in

Tibia rotated outward — the tubercle is pulled out

The two cancel at the foot — so the leg looks straight

The knee between them is the only place the twist shows

HOW IT IS CORRECTED

01

Quantify both bones

CT torsional profile of the entire limb — hip to ankle — measuring femoral anteversion and tibial torsion separately, so that each bone’s contribution is known.

02

Plan the rotation

The osteotomies are placed and rotated in software until the knee sits square to the direction of travel. Where both bones need correcting, the plan balances the two.

03

Cut through a small incision

The osteotomy is made through a minimally invasive approach and the rotation is measured precisely as it is applied, so the correction achieved matches the correction planned; a patient-specific guide designed from the plan carries the planned rotation into theatre.

04

Fix and protect

Once the growth plates have closed, the rotated bone is fixed with an intramedullary nail — the less traumatic technique, and one that can be walked on from the start. In the rare adolescent whose torsion is severe enough to correct before maturity, it is fixed over a plate that stays clear of the growth plates. Soft-tissue procedures — MPFL reconstruction, tubercle transfer — are often performed at the same operation or staged.

THE HONEST POSITION

A large operation for a problem that is easy to overlook.

A large operation for a problem that is easy to overlook.

Derotational osteotomy is limb reconstruction applied to the knee. Recovery is measured in months, the bone must heal before it can be fully loaded, and it should not be undertaken for mild torsion or for pain that has not been carefully attributed to rotation. But for the patient whose kneecap has dislocated for years despite surgery, and whose torsional profile explains why, it can be the answer.

CHILDREN & ADOLESCENTS

Growing bones change the plan.

Growing bones change the plan.

Growing bones change the plan.

Most first dislocations happen between twelve and eighteen. The instinct to wait is understandable — but in Dr Alttahir’s experience the adolescents who come back with a second dislocation and a fractured joint surface are the ones who waited. A child who has dislocated and whose anatomy carries risk factors is offered the ligament reconstruction now; the growth plates shape only which bony corrections can follow, and when.

Ligament reconstruction that spares the growth plates

While the growth plates are open, the MPFL is reconstructed with an allograft and fixation placed to stay clear of them — restoring the restraint without interfering with growth. It is not deferred to skeletal maturity.

Guided growth for alignment

Where knock-knee is driving the instability, the remaining growth can be used to straighten the leg gradually with small temporary implants, rather than cutting bone.

Bone procedures mostly wait their turn

Moving the tibial tubercle is deferred until the tubercle’s growth plate has closed. Derotation is reserved before maturity for severely excessive torsion, and then done over a plate clear of the growth plates — the less traumatic intramedullary technique waits for the plates to close. Trochleoplasty is not performed in this practice at any age.

Rehabilitation that fits a school year

Strengthening and return to sport are planned around school, training and a body that is still changing — with parents part of the goals from the first visit.

Children and adolescents are seen with a parent or guardian. A referral from a GP, paediatrician or other specialist is all that’s needed — bring any previous X-rays or MRI scans to the first appointment.

THE OPERATION

Six stages, one plan.

Six stages, one plan.

Six stages, one plan.

Operating time varies with what is being corrected — around an hour for an isolated MPFL reconstruction, one to two hours for a combined bony and soft-tissue procedure. Most patients stay one to two nights.

01

01

ANAESTHESIA

Regional block and general

Regional block and general

A femoral or adductor canal block for post-operative pain relief, combined with general anaesthesia. Multimodal pain protocols reduce opioid requirements in the first days.

02

02

ARTHROSCOPY & EXAMINATION

Confirming the pattern

Confirming the pattern

With the muscles relaxed, the kneecap’s tracking and the degree of lateral translation are assessed directly. The joint is then inspected arthroscopically — loose fragments are dealt with and the cartilage graded — and the outer retinaculum is released where it is tight.

03

03

BONY CORRECTION

Osteotomy, where planned

Osteotomy, where planned

Where torsion, alignment or tubercle position is being corrected, the bone is cut and repositioned first. A derotation is made through a small incision and the rotation measured precisely as it is applied, with a patient-specific guide printed from the plan; a tubercle transfer moves the attachment to its planned position. Fixation is applied and checked on X-ray.

04

04

SOFT-TISSUE RECONSTRUCTION

Rebuilding the medial restraint

Rebuilding the medial restraint

The MPFL is reconstructed with an allograft in every patient who has dislocated. The femoral attachment point is located precisely on X-ray, because a few millimetres of error changes how the graft tensions through the range of motion.

05

05

TENSIONING & TRACKING

Checked through the full range

Checked through the full range

The graft is tensioned with the knee at the angle where the kneecap first engages the groove, then tracking is checked from full extension to deep flexion before final fixation. Over-tightening is as much a failure as under-tightening.

06

06

CLOSURE

Layered closure and a brace

Layered closure and a brace

Wounds are closed in layers. The knee is placed in a brace, and the weight-bearing and movement protocol depends entirely on whether bone was cut.

RECOVERY

Depends on whether bone was cut.

Depends on whether bone was cut.

Depends on whether bone was cut.

A ligament reconstruction and a derotational osteotomy have very different recoveries. Yours follows the operation you actually had — and how much weight the leg can take early depends on what was cut and how it was fixed, not on the calendar.

MPFL RECONSTRUCTION ALONE

3 to 6 months

3 to 6 months

Soft tissue heals faster than bone. Full weight-bearing as tolerated from the first days, in a range-of-motion brace; the graft takes months to mature, which is what sets the return-to-sport timeline.

TYPICALLY

Full weight-bearing in a range-of-motion brace from the first days

Physiotherapy from the first fortnight

Return to pivoting sport at four to six months, once strength and control are restored

TIBIAL TUBERCLE OSTEOTOMY, WITH OR WITHOUT MPFL

4 to 9 months

4 to 9 months

The moved tubercle must unite before it can take the full pull of the quadriceps — but it is fixed securely enough to stand on from the start.

TYPICALLY

Weight-bearing as tolerated from the first days

Range-of-motion brace locked between 0 and 45 degrees of flexion for six weeks

X-rays confirm union before full loading and sport

FEMORAL DEROTATION OVER A NAIL

6 to 12 months

6 to 12 months

The femur is cut through a small incision, rotated by a precisely measured amount and fixed with an intramedullary nail — strong enough to walk on from the start. The bone takes months to heal fully, but the recovery moves on early.

TYPICALLY

Weight-bearing as tolerated, usually with crutches, for six weeks

Rehabilitation retraining gait to the new alignment

Return to sport once the bone has united and strength has returned

DISTAL FEMORAL OSTEOTOMY

6 to 12 months

6 to 12 months

A realignment cut just above the knee, fixed with a plate. How much weight it can take early depends on the quality of the bone and the size of the correction.

TYPICALLY

Good bone: half weight-bearing on crutches for the first six weeks

Lower-quality bone or a large correction: about a fifth of body weight on two crutches for six weeks, then a single crutch for six weeks

Then progression as the X-rays allow; full recovery takes months

TRUE OF ALL OF THEM

Quadriceps strength decides the result

The kneecap is held by muscle as much as by ligament and bone. Rehabilitation is not an add-on to the operation; it is half of it.

Swelling lingers

Anterior knee swelling for three to six months is normal and is not a sign of failure.

Confidence returns last

Patients who have dislocated for years take time to trust the knee, sometimes long after it is structurally sound. That is expected, and physiotherapy addresses it directly.

WHAT TO EXPECT

What to expect.

What to expect.

What to expect.

Stabilisation surgery is reliable at stopping dislocation when the causes have been identified and addressed. It is less reliable at removing anterior knee pain entirely, and it cannot undo cartilage damage that has already happened — which is the argument for treating early.

Stability is the goal, and usually the result

When the bony drivers have been corrected alongside the ligament, recurrent dislocation is uncommon. Re-dislocation remains possible, particularly where severe trochlear dysplasia is present and cannot be fully addressed.

Pain may persist

Anterior knee pain often improves as tracking normalises, but cartilage damage from years of maltracking does not reverse. Where the cartilage behind the kneecap is already worn, pain may continue despite a stable knee. Where the arthritis is confined to the front of the knee, patellofemoral replacement is discussed as a salvage option.

Realignment protects cartilage; it cannot restore it

Correcting the alignment takes the abnormal load off the cartilage behind the kneecap and aims to stop further wear. Cartilage already lost does not grow back, and where the arthritis is established the conversation turns to salvage options.

Recovery is measured in months

Even the soft-tissue operation takes three to six months to return to full function. Bony correction takes longer, and rehabilitation is a daily commitment through most of it.

The knee will feel different

Some stiffness, altered sensation around the incisions, and a kneecap that sits differently from the other side are usual. Hardware can be felt under the skin at the tubercle or along the tibia and is occasionally removed later.

Sport is possible, with caveats

Many patients return to sport, including pivoting sport, once strength and control are back. The timeline depends on the operation, and for some derotation patients the answer is a change of activity rather than a return to the original one.

Complications happen

The risks common to operations on the lower limb are infection, bleeding, blood clots in the leg or lung, injury to a nerve or blood vessel, stiffness, pain that persists, slow or failed healing where bone is cut, the complications of anaesthesia, and the need for further surgery.

The risks particular to kneecap surgery are a fracture of the kneecap or shin through the bone cuts, the kneecap becoming unstable towards the inside, stiffness, the kneecap dislocating again, and, in children, disturbance of growth.

Their likelihood depends on the procedure and is discussed in detail before surgery.

COSTS & HEALTH FUNDS

A clear conversation about cost.

A clear conversation about cost.

A clear conversation about cost.

Surgery is a financial decision as well as a medical one. Fees are discussed with you first and take your circumstances into account; once surgery is booked, and before the operation, you receive written informed financial consent with a complete estimate.

FEES AND HEALTH FUNDS

Agreed before surgery

Dr Alttahir’s fees are set by reference to the AMA List of Medical Services and Fees. What you may pay out of pocket, and whether any health-fund arrangement applies, depends on the procedure and your cover; it is discussed with you first and set out in writing before anything is booked.

Once surgery is booked you receive a complete written estimate of Dr Alttahir’s fee, the Medicare and health-fund contributions and the amount you would pay, with a note on the separate accounts from the anaesthetist, surgical assistant, hospital and any imaging or pathology. The patient-specific guide used for an osteotomy is quoted separately.

FEES AND HEALTH FUNDS

Agreed before surgery

Dr Alttahir’s fees are set by reference to the AMA List of Medical Services and Fees. What you may pay out of pocket, and whether any health-fund arrangement applies, depends on the procedure and your cover; it is discussed with you first and set out in writing before anything is booked.

Once surgery is booked you receive a complete written estimate of Dr Alttahir’s fee, the Medicare and health-fund contributions and the amount you would pay, with a note on the separate accounts from the anaesthetist, surgical assistant, hospital and any imaging or pathology. The patient-specific guide used for an osteotomy is quoted separately.

TYPICAL FEE COMPONENTS

What’s quoted to you

Surgeon’s fee

Anaesthetist’s fee

Surgical assistant’s fee

Hospital and theatre fees

Implant costs — anchors, screws, plates or nail (if not privately insured)

Each component is itemised so you can see what is and isn’t covered by your fund — and what you may owe out of pocket.

TYPICAL FEE COMPONENTS

What’s quoted to you

Surgeon’s fee

Anaesthetist’s fee

Surgical assistant’s fee

Hospital and theatre fees

Implant costs — anchors, screws, plates or nail (if not privately insured)

Each component is itemised so you can see what is and isn’t covered by your fund — and what you may owe out of pocket.

This page does not constitute a fee quotation. Costs and health-fund coverage vary by individual circumstance and are confirmed individually in writing before surgery. This page has been written in line with the Ahpra Guidelines for advertising a regulated health service.

FOR REFERRERS

When to refer an unstable kneecap.

When to refer an unstable kneecap.

When to refer an unstable kneecap.

Referrals are welcomed from general practitioners, sports physicians, paediatricians and orthopaedic colleagues; physiotherapists who suspect a torsional cause can ask the patient’s GP to refer. Dr Alttahir assesses every dislocation, including a first one, because a second dislocation can bring an osteochondral fracture with it — early referral for assessment often changes the plan.

ROUTINE

A first patellar dislocation in an adolescent or young adult — for risk assessment before the next one

Second or subsequent patellar dislocation

Persistent instability or apprehension after a first dislocation treated non-operatively

Anterior knee pain with maltracking on examination

Patient asking whether surgery is needed

COMPLEX

Failed previous MPFL reconstruction or stabilisation

Suspected miserable malalignment — in-toeing gait, forward-pointing feet, patellae facing inward

Instability with significant valgus or limb-length asymmetry

Recurrent dislocation with open growth plates

Chronic dislocation or a kneecap that no longer reduces

Isolated patellofemoral arthritis in a younger patient, with or without ongoing instability

PLEASE INCLUDE

Number and dates of dislocation episodes

Knee X-rays including a skyline view

MRI if already performed

CT torsional profile if already performed — otherwise it is arranged

EOS or long-leg standing alignment films where limb alignment is in question (Macquarie Medical Imaging at Macquarie University Hospital, or PRP Imaging at Norwest Private Hospital)

Growth status if under eighteen

Previous operative reports, if any

Sporting demands and what the patient wants to return to

Trochleoplasty is not performed in this practice. Severe trochlear dysplasia is assessed and managed through the other corrective options, and where trochleoplasty is the most appropriate treatment, referral onward is arranged.

SYDNEY ADVANCED ORTHOPAEDICS · (02) 8882 9011 · MACQUARIE · NORWEST · EAST SYDNEY

LIMB RECONSTRUCTION SERVICE NSW · (02) 9602 1113 · CAMPBELLTOWN

COMMON QUESTIONS

What patients most often ask.

What patients most often ask.

What patients most often ask.

Often because a bony driver — the tubercle position, torsion, alignment or patellar height — was still acting on the graft, which was asked to hold against forces it cannot resist. A torsional CT and a 3D model of the limb are the first step in working out what is driving the knee now.

Often because a bony driver — the tubercle position, torsion, alignment or patellar height — was still acting on the graft, which was asked to hold against forces it cannot resist. A torsional CT and a 3D model of the limb are the first step in working out what is driving the knee now.

BEGIN

Measure it
properly.

Measure it
properly.

Measure it
properly.

Bring any X-rays, MRI or CT you already have. The first consultation is about finding what is actually driving the instability — and for some patients that assessment confirms a plan already in place. Either way, you leave knowing which.

Bring any X-rays, MRI or CT you already have. The first consultation is about finding what is actually driving the instability — and for some patients that assessment confirms a plan already in place. Either way, you leave knowing which.

This page provides general information about patellar instability and its surgical treatment and is not a substitute for individual medical advice. Surgery carries risks; outcomes vary between patients. Trochleoplasty is not performed in this practice. Diagrams are schematic and illustrative only. Advertising on this site complies with the AHPRA Guidelines for advertising a regulated health service.