
FAILED & PAINFUL JOINT REPLACEMENT
AT A GLANCE
The whole page in one minute — the detail follows below.
WHO THIS IS FOR
A hip, knee or ankle replacement that is painful, loose, unstable or infected, or that has fractured around the implant — including patients who have been told nothing more can be done.
HOW YOU ARE ASSESSED
Operative reports and implant records, weight-bearing X-rays, CT or MRI with metal-artefact reduction, blood tests and an aspirate where infection is possible, EOS alignment films of both legs and a 3D model of the remaining bone.
THE OPTIONS
Observation where the implant is stable; revision of one component; full revision with cones, augments or a custom implant where bone has been lost; staged surgery with an antibiotic spacer for infection.
THE COMMITMENT
Bigger than the first operation: several nights in hospital, a walking aid for some weeks, early loading set by the reconstruction, and six to twelve months to reach the best result.
NEXT STEP
Call the rooms on (02) 8882 9011 or (02) 9602 1113. A GP referral is needed for the Medicare rebate.
If it is urgent
Suspected infection, a fracture around an implant or a dislocation: call the rooms first, the same day — Dr Alttahir will try to arrange your care directly, often with an admission to the ward at Norwest Private or Macquarie University Hospital. If you cannot reach the rooms, go to the emergency department — Norwest Private Hospital where possible — and let the rooms know so that he can be involved.
WHY REVISION IS DIFFERENT
Most revisions can be done with standard revision systems — modular stems, sleeves and cones. When bone loss is severe, custom 3D-printed titanium components and patient-specific guides are designed to restore length, alignment and stability.
This is where a limb-reconstruction background becomes valuable. Dr Alttahir’s training combines joint replacement with deformity correction, bone-loss management, and surgeon-led 3D planning — the same skill set required in complex revision arthroplasty.
A FIRST JOINT REPLACEMENT
Native anatomy preserved
Predictable bone landmarks
Standard off-the-shelf implants
Established cut guides and references
Usually 60–90 minutes in theatre
A REVISION
Scar tissue and distorted anatomy from the previous surgery
Bone loss that may need augments, cones or custom implants
Removing the old components without fracturing bone
CT-based 3D planning and custom guides where needed
Often three hours or more in theatre
SIGNS YOUR REPLACEMENT MAY HAVE FAILED
Most primary joint replacements last many years — but no implant is permanent. Wear, loosening, infection and trauma can shorten its life. If you recognise any of the following, talk to your GP about a referral.
01
New or returning pain
Pain at rest, with activity, or at night — months or years after surgery.
02
Instability or giving way
A sense the joint is unreliable, slipping, or dislocating.
03
A new clunk, or a feeling that the joint shifts
Painless clicking is common after a knee replacement and is not a concern. A new clunk with pain or giving way is different.
04
Reduced range of motion
Stiffness developing months after the initial recovery.
05
Swelling or warmth
Persistent swelling, warmth, redness, or a sinus discharging fluid.
06
Limp or shortened limb
A new limp, leg-length difference, or loss of confidence walking.
07
Imaging changes
X-ray or CT changes suggesting loosening, wear, bone loss around the implant, or fracture.
08
Unexplained fever
Particularly with joint pain — needs urgent assessment for infection.
Suspected infection is urgent
A red, hot, swollen replaced joint — especially with fever or a wound that is leaking — is treated as a surgical emergency until proven otherwise.
Ring the rooms on the day: suspected infection is triaged by phone, and Dr Alttahir will try to arrange your admission directly, usually to the ward at Norwest Private or Macquarie University Hospital. If you cannot reach the rooms, go to the emergency department (Norwest Private Hospital where possible) and let the rooms know so that he can be involved.
Tell any doctor who sees you that you have a joint replacement, so that, if you are well enough, samples can be taken before antibiotics are started. If you are unwell with sepsis, antibiotics are started without delay.
COMMON CAUSES
The exact cause matters because treatment can range from observation to single-stage reconstruction, staged infection surgery, custom implants or fusion.
01
Loosening without infection
The implant loses its bond with the bone (aseptic loosening). One of the most common reasons for revision.
02
Wear of the plastic bearing
Gradual wear of the plastic surface releases particles that can cause bone loss around the implant (osteolysis).
03
Infection around the implant
Bacterial infection of the joint replacement (prosthetic joint infection) — early, delayed or late. Often needs staged surgery: the implant removed, the infection cleared, then a new implant.
04
Instability or dislocation
Particularly in hip replacements, or where the ligaments no longer hold a knee or ankle replacement stable.
05
A fracture around the implant
A break in the bone next to the implant (periprosthetic fracture), often after a fall.
06
Components in the wrong position
Implants placed outside the safe range for alignment can cause early pain and wear.
07
Metal sensitivity or corrosion
Less common, but recognised — especially in older metal-on-metal designs.
08
Pain from a neighbouring joint
Sometimes the replacement itself is fine, and the pain is referred from the spine, hip or knee.
REVISION BY JOINT
Each joint fails in its own ways and is reconstructed with its own toolkit. Select a joint for the specific detail.
Knee
Hip
Ankle
KNEE · STEMS, CONES, HINGES
Revision total knee replacement
Revision knee replacement addresses failed primary knees due to loosening, wear, instability, infection, malalignment or fracture. The operation may require removing well-fixed components, managing bone loss with metal cones or sleeves, restoring joint line and limb alignment, and re-balancing the ligaments.
THE TOOLKIT
Stemmed femoral and tibial components for stability
Porous metal cones or sleeves where bone has been lost
Hinged implants where the ligaments can no longer stabilise the knee
Robotic-assisted bone cuts, executed to the 3D plan with ROSA — an extension of the system’s listed use in first-time knee replacement
Staged revision with an antibiotic spacer for confirmed infection
Custom 3D-printed components for severe bone loss

THE APPROACH
Every revision follows the same disciplined sequence — diagnosis first, reconstruction last.
WORKUP
Diagnose before deciding to revise
Detailed history, examination, weight-bearing X-rays, often CT with metal-artefact reduction, blood tests for infection (CRP, ESR), sometimes a joint aspirate or nuclear imaging, and review of all prior operative notes and implant records.
3D PLANNING
CT-based modelling and analysis
For complex cases, Dr Alttahir segments the CT in Materialise Mimics and 3‑matic, occasionally SolidWorks, himself. Bone defects are measured, and the new joint line, alignment, leg length and component position are planned in 3D — and reviewed with you — before you enter theatre.
IMPLANT STRATEGY
Standard, modular, or custom
Most revisions use modular off-the-shelf revision implants with augments, sleeves or stems. For severe or unusual defects, custom 3D-printed titanium components and patient-specific guides may be designed.
ONE STAGE OR TWO
One operation or two
Failures without infection are usually dealt with in one operation. Confirmed deep infection usually needs two: the implant is removed and an antibiotic spacer placed, then — commonly six to twelve weeks later — the new implant goes in.
SURGERY
The reconstruction itself
Performed at Macquarie University Hospital, Norwest Private, Campbelltown Private or East Sydney Private, with experienced anaesthetic, theatre and infectious-disease support where required. In Sydney, complex revisions are centred at Macquarie University Hospital. Dr Alttahir also performs revision joint replacement as a visiting surgeon at Burjeel Medical City, Abu Dhabi.
REHABILITATION
Recovery takes longer than a first replacement
How much weight you can put through the leg, and when, is set for you individually. Physiotherapy usually runs over several months, and you are followed with X-rays for many years.
WHEN STANDARD ISN’T ENOUGH
When bone loss is severe, anatomy is distorted, or off-the-shelf implants don’t fit — CT-based 3D modelling and custom 3D-printed titanium components are needed. Custom triflange cups for a pelvis that has lost its bone or separated. Custom 3D-printed talus components for an ankle replacement where the talus has collapsed. Patient-specific osteotomy and resection guides for complex limb reconstruction. Each is designed by Dr Alttahir from the patient’s own CT and printed in medical-grade titanium by manufacturers working under the TGA’s requirements for patient-matched devices.
HONEST OUTCOMES
Revision joint replacement is one of the more demanding operations in orthopaedics. Outcomes are individual — but realistic expectations are part of good consent.
Recovery takes longer than a first replacement
Many patients take six to twelve months to reach their best — and the early milestones, such as walking unaided, driving and work, come later than after a first replacement.
Goals are individualised
The realistic goal depends on what went wrong, your age and activity, and the reconstruction performed. This is discussed clearly with you before surgery.
Complications are more common than after a first replacement
The risks common to operations on the lower limb are infection, bleeding, blood clots in the leg or lung, injury to a nerve or blood vessel, stiffness, pain that persists, slow or failed healing where bone is cut, the complications of anaesthesia, and the need for further surgery.
The risks particular to revision are a fracture during surgery, dislocation, the infection returning, loosening, a blood transfusion, and, rarely, loss of the limb or life.
The likelihood depends on the failure mode and individual circumstances.
Pain relief is the usual aim
Most revisions for a clear mechanical problem are done to reduce pain and restore function. Results vary, and the degree of improvement cannot be promised.
Implants are not permanent
Even a successful revision has a limited lifespan. Long-term follow-up with X-rays is part of the plan.
COSTS & HEALTH FUNDS
Surgery is a financial decision as well as a medical one. Once surgery is booked, and before the operation, you receive written informed financial consent with a complete estimate.
FEES & HEALTH FUNDS
Discussed with you first
Medibank members may be eligible for the fund’s no-out-of-pocket joint replacement program, which can include revision surgery at Macquarie University Hospital and East Sydney Private Hospital. Eligibility is confirmed with Medibank before anything is booked (as at October 2026).
For other patients, fees take your circumstances into account. Known-gap and no-gap arrangements are available in selected cases.
TYPICAL FEE COMPONENTS
What’s quoted to you
• Surgeon’s fee
• Anaesthetist’s fee
• Surgical assistant’s fee
• Hospital and theatre fees
• Implant costs — standard implants are covered by most funds; custom implants require ex-gratia approval from your health fund, which the rooms request on your behalf
Each component is itemised individually so you can see what is and isn’t covered by your fund — and what you may owe out of pocket.
This page does not constitute a fee quotation. Costs and health-fund coverage vary by individual circumstance and are confirmed individually in writing before surgery. This page has been written in line with the Ahpra Guidelines for advertising a regulated health service.
FOR REFERRERS
The more complete the referral, the faster the patient gets a plan. None of this is compulsory — send what you have and the rooms will arrange the rest. Suspected infection is treated as urgent — please call the rooms directly. Do not start antibiotics before cultures have been taken if at all possible.
HELPFUL TO INCLUDE
Index operation date, surgeon, hospital and the operative report
Implant brand, model and size (usually in the operation report)
Recent X-rays (weight-bearing where possible) and any CT or MRI — ideally with metal-artefact reduction (MARS sequences for MRI)
Inflammatory markers (CRP, ESR) and any aspirate cultures
Comorbidities relevant to anaesthesia and infection risk
Functional limitations and the patient’s goals
IF NEW IMAGING IS BEING ARRANGED
For any revision joint: an EOS scan of both lower limbs (Macquarie Medical Imaging at Macquarie University Hospital, or PRP Imaging at Norwest Private Hospital), or long-leg standing alignment X-rays of both lower limbs, weight-bearing. Then by joint:
Hips — weight-bearing pelvis and both hips
Knees — weight-bearing both knees
Ankles — weight-bearing both ankles and feet, with Saltzman (hindfoot alignment) views
TRIAGE
Emergency
Same day. Open fracture · compartment syndrome · a limb without circulation or sensation · a septic patient: call 000 or send to the nearest emergency department, and phone the rooms so Dr Alttahir can take over care. Dislocated joint replacement: phone the rooms so the admission can be arranged — to the ward at Norwest Private or Macquarie University Hospital, or through the Norwest Private emergency department or the WiSE Specialist Emergency Clinic. If the rooms cannot be reached, the nearest emergency department, with the rooms informed.
Urgent
Phone the rooms the same day; admission or an appointment is arranged from that call. Suspected joint replacement infection in a stable patient · fracture around an implant · wound breakdown · sudden instability of a replaced joint · a recently replaced joint that has become painful · acute deformity after trauma.
Priority
Within 10 days. Painful or loosening joint replacement · non-union · progressive or complex deformity · failed ankle surgery · second opinion before a booked operation.
Routine
Usually within 1–4 weeks. Elective arthritis · bunions and forefoot · flat foot and high arch · patellar instability · bow legs and knock knees · long-standing limb-length difference · other second opinions.
SYDNEY ADVANCED ORTHOPAEDICS · (02) 8882 9011 · MACQUARIE · NORWEST · EAST SYDNEY
LIMB RECONSTRUCTION SERVICE NSW · (02) 9602 1113 · CAMPBELLTOWN
COMMON QUESTIONS
RELATED
3D planning & custom implants
CT-based 3D planning and custom implants for complex cases.
Complex limb reconstruction
Limb deformity correction, lengthening, osseointegration.
Total ankle replacement
Motion-preserving ankle replacement and the custom 3D-printed talus component.
Complex second opinion
Independent review for failed surgery and complex decisions.
BEGIN
CALL THE ROOMS
MACQUARIE · NORWEST · EAST SYDNEY
CAMPBELLTOWN
This page provides general information about revision joint replacement and is not a substitute for individual medical advice. Revision surgery carries higher risks than primary joint replacement; outcomes vary between patients and depend on the mode of failure and individual circumstances. Custom implant procedures are performed in selected cases only. Diagrams are schematic and illustrative only. Advertising on this site complies with the AHPRA Guidelines for advertising a regulated health service.
