A SUBSPECIALTY WITHIN FOOT & ANKLE SURGERY
AN ALIGNED REPLACEMENT · AN ALIGNED FOOT · A STABLE JOINT · A SHOEABLE FOOT · STRYKER INFINITY, INBONE AND INVISION · CT-BASED PROPHECY GUIDES · WHAT GOES WITH A REPLACEMENT →
CORONAL AXIS
SAGITTAL AXIS
TIBIA GUTTER
TALAR GUTTER
VARUS CORRECTION
IMPLANT
AT A GLANCE
The whole page in one minute — the detail follows below.
WHO THIS IS FOR
End-stage ankle arthritis — after injury, inflammatory disease or long-standing deformity — that limits walking, in a patient who wants to keep ankle movement rather than fuse the joint.
HOW YOU ARE ASSESSED
Examination of the whole leg and foot, weight-bearing ankle, foot and hindfoot alignment X-rays, and a CT for patient-specific planning; deformity cases are modelled in 3D first.
THE OPTIONS
Non-operative care and bracing; realignment or fusion where a replacement is not the right answer; total ankle replacement, often with hindfoot or ligament procedures so the ankle sits straight and stable; a custom 3D-printed talus component where the talus has collapsed.
THE COMMITMENT
A boot rather than a plaster, a wound check at two weeks, weight-bearing at six weeks — earlier where bone quality allows; a comfortable, shoeable foot usually by three to six months, with improvement continuing over a year.
NEXT STEP
Call the rooms on (02) 8882 9011 or (02) 9602 1113. A GP referral is needed for the Medicare rebate; fees are discussed with you first and confirmed in writing once surgery is booked.
ANKLE ARTHRITIS
POST-TRAUMATIC — SERIES OF 406 END-STAGE ANKLES
ADULTS OVER 50 WITH SYMPTOMATIC ANKLE ARTHRITIS
FOLLOW A FRACTURE, 1 IN 6 A LIGAMENT INJURY
THE FIRST QUESTION
SOURCES: VALDERRABANO ET AL., CLIN ORTHOP RELAT RES 2009 · MURRAY ET AL., PLOS ONE 2018
THE PRACTICE
Ankle replacement is a core part of Dr Mustafa Alttahir’s practice. He learned the operation from Dr Tim O’Carrigan, who built a dedicated ankle replacement practice in Sydney, and continues that practice following Dr O’Carrigan’s death in February 2026 — the approach on this page is his, refined with the 3D planning and custom-implant work Dr Alttahir has developed since.
He performs ankle replacement, including with a custom 3D-printed talus component, at all four of his Sydney hospitals and as a visiting surgeon at the Al Muderis Osseointegration Clinic, Burjeel Medical City, Abu Dhabi.
EVERY REPLACEMENT IS JUDGED ON FOUR THINGS
01
02
03
04

DR ALTTAHIR IN THEATRE
FOUNDATIONS · DR TIM O’CARRIGAN, SYDNEY · IBRA FELLOWSHIP · PROFESSOR VICTOR VALDERRABANO, SWITZERLAND · PROFESSOR MARIO HERRERA-PEREZ, SPAIN · PRINCE OF WALES HOSPITAL FOOT & ANKLE UNIT
STRYKER PROPHECY CT GUIDES — DESIGNED IN-HOUSE WHEN THE MANUFACTURER CANNOT MAKE THEM · CUSTOM 3D-PRINTED TALUS COMPONENT FOR AN ANKLE REPLACEMENT · PUBLISHED ON TOTAL ANKLE REPLACEMENT · FOUR SYDNEY HOSPITALS · ABU DHABI
PATIENTS OF DR O’CARRIGAN
CAMPBELLTOWN · LIMB RECONSTRUCTION SERVICE NEW SOUTH WALES
MACQUARIE UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL · SYDNEY ADVANCED ORTHOPAEDICS
THE DECISION
THE HONEST ANSWER
Modern replacement designs are good — and so is a well-performed fusion. The right operation depends on age, activity, occupation, deformity, bone quality, ligament integrity and the state of the joints around the ankle. Dr Alttahir makes the decision with the patient, with a clear account of what either operation can and cannot offer. In very select cases a fusion done years earlier can be taken down and converted to a replacement.
CANDIDACY
GENERALLY GOOD CANDIDATES
Confirmed on weight-bearing X‑rays and CT.
Bracing, footwear changes, injections and anti-inflammatories have failed.
Especially in the talus.
At the same operation, or in a first stage before the replacement.
Lateral and medial (deltoid) stability.
Including willingness to moderate high-impact activity for the life of the implant.
OFTEN BETTER SUITED TO FUSION
Beyond what osteotomies, staging and implant alignment can compensate.
Severe osteoporosis or extensive death of the talus (avascular necrosis) — a custom 3D-printed talus component is the exception in selected cases.
Manual labour, contact sport, military and agricultural work.
Replacement is deferred, or fusion is chosen instead.
Severe scarring, adherent skin grafts or peripheral vascular disease — wound healing and infection risk.
Replacement is generally contraindicated.
ALIGNMENT & STABILITY
01 · HINDFOOT ALIGNMENT
02 · STABILITY
03 · FOREFOOT BALANCE
04 · SOFT TISSUE
ONE OPERATION
TWO STAGES
EVERY CORRECTION IS CAREFULLY PLANNED AND SIMULATED IN 3D BASED ON THE PATIENT’S OWN WEIGHT-BEARING CT SCAN BEFORE THE DAY OF SURGERY · READ ABOUT 3D PLANNING →
THE OPERATION
WORKUP
Standing X‑rays of the ankle and foot, including a hindfoot alignment (Saltzman) view; a CT for the plan; MRI where the soft tissues or the talus are in question; and examination of alignment, ligament stability, the circulation and the nerves.
PLANNING
The CT follows Stryker’s Prophecy protocol and the cutting guides are made from it. Dr Alttahir reviews and adjusts the plan — implant size and position, and each osteotomy — and designs the guides himself when the manufacturer cannot make them. He uses patient-specific guides because, in his hands, they make the cuts more accurate and the operation quicker and more controlled, with fewer X-rays in theatre. Where there is deformity, he models the limb in 3D first, so the alignment problem is understood before the implant is chosen.
ANAESTHESIA
Most patients have a regional nerve block for pain control after surgery, combined with a light general anaesthetic. The anaesthetist decides this with you.
APPROACH
A longitudinal incision at the front of the ankle, between the tendon that lifts the foot (tibialis anterior) and the tendon that lifts the big toe (extensor hallucis longus), exposes the tibia and talus. The heel shift, forefoot osteotomies and ligament work are done through their own incisions, several of them minimally invasive.
IMPLANTATION
The worn surfaces are cut away precisely through the guides, and the tibial and talar components are impacted into prepared bone with a polyethylene insert between them. Stryker Infinity is the standard implant; Inbone, with a stem into the tibia, where bone quality or deformity call for more fixation; Invision for revisions and alongside a custom 3D-printed talus component.
CLOSURE
The wounds are closed in layers and the ankle goes into a walking boot rather than a plaster slab unless there is a reason for one — the first step of the recovery protocol below.
SIGNATURE CAPABILITY
PATIENT-SPECIFIC TALUS COMPONENT · CUSTOM 3D-PRINTED TITANIUM · ILLUSTRATIVE WORKFLOW
This is a specialist procedure performed in a small number of centres across the world. It is a salvage procedure with limited long-term data. Its risks include infection, loosening or sinking of the implant, failure of the joints beneath it to fuse to the implant, and conversion to a fusion if it fails. Outcomes depend on individual case complexity and are discussed in detail before any decision is made.
REVISION ANKLE REPLACEMENT

INBONE II · MODULAR TIBIAL STEM · TRAY · POLY · TALAR COMPONENT
Replacement of one or both components with the Invision revision system — sometimes with a custom 3D-printed talus component where the talus has subsided or collapsed.
When replacement is no longer viable; the ankle and subtalar joints are fused together using a long intramedullary nail or plate.
Implants removed and an antibiotic-loaded spacer placed; antibiotics, intravenous at first and then tablets, for a course set by the infectious diseases physician; definitive reconstruction once the infection has cleared.
For talar collapse — discussed in detail in the previous section.
COMMON MODES OF FAILURE
01 —
One of the most common patterns of loosening — the talar component sinks into the talus over time.
02 —
Like in hip and knee replacements — the plastic bearing surface eventually wears.
03 —
Loss of fixation between implant and bone without infection.
04 —
Acute, delayed or late — managed similarly to infected hip/knee replacements.
05 —
Fracture in the tibia, fibula or talus around the implant.
06 —
Implants placed outside the safe zone — early pain, accelerated wear.
RECOVERY
WEEK 0
Hospital stay
One to three nights typically. A regional block for pain, and a boot rather than a plaster slab unless there is a reason for one; early mobilisation on crutches, non-weight-bearing on the operated ankle.
WEEKS 0–6
The boot, without weight — usually
Non-weight-bearing while the bone grows onto the implant and any bone cuts heal. With good bone and no osteotomy to protect, static loading — standing with weight through the planted foot, not walking — can start as early as the first week.
WEEKS 6–12
Transition to a shoe
Out of the boot into supportive footwear, typically by 10–12 weeks. Range-of-motion and strengthening physiotherapy continues.
WHAT TO EXPECT
Pain relief is the primary goal
Most patients experience meaningful improvement in pain and function — but the precise outcome cannot be guaranteed for any individual.
Motion is preserved, not perfected
A replaced ankle retains useful motion but rarely matches a native, healthy ankle. Compared with fusion, however, the difference is substantial.
Implants are not permanent
Modern ankle implants have improved markedly, but like hip and knee implants they have a finite lifespan. In the Australian registry about 13.0% of primary ankle replacements for osteoarthritis had been revised at ten years across all eras, with lower figures so far for implants placed since 2015; younger age raises the risk (AOANJRR 2026 Ankle Supplementary Report), and higher body weight may also do so. Long-term follow-up is part of the plan.
Activity is moderated long-term
Most patients return to walking, cycling, swimming, golf and similar activities. High-impact sport, jumping and heavy manual labour are generally discouraged.
The procedures around the replacement add to the recovery
Osteotomies and ligament reconstructions have to heal as well as the replacement, so protected weight-bearing is often longer, and a staged correction means two operations and two recoveries.
Complications happen
The risks common to operations on the lower limb are infection, bleeding, blood clots in the leg or lung, injury to a nerve or blood vessel, stiffness, pain that persists, slow or failed healing where bone is cut, the complications of anaesthesia, and the need for further surgery.
The risks particular to ankle replacement are wound-healing problems, a fracture of the ankle bones during or after surgery, loosening or sinking of the implant, cysts in the bone around it, ongoing pain or stiffness, and conversion to a fusion; amputation is rare.
Their likelihood in your case is discussed in detail before surgery.
Revision is harder than primary
If a replacement does eventually fail, revision options exist but are more demanding. This is part of the decision when choosing replacement over fusion in younger patients.
COSTS & HEALTH FUNDS
FEES AND HEALTH FUNDS
Agreed before surgery
Dr Alttahir’s fees are set by reference to the AMA List of Medical Services and Fees. No-gap arrangements are not offered for ankle replacement, so there is an out-of-pocket cost; it is discussed with you first and set out in writing before anything is booked.
A custom 3D-printed talus component for an ankle replacement is a custom implant and requires ex-gratia approval from your health fund, which the rooms request on your behalf. Once surgery is booked you receive a complete written estimate of Dr Alttahir’s fee, the Medicare and health-fund contributions and the amount you would pay, with a note on the separate accounts from the anaesthetist, surgical assistant, hospital and any imaging or pathology.
TYPICAL FEE COMPONENTS
What’s quoted to you
• Surgeon’s fee
• Anaesthetist’s fee
• Surgical assistant’s fee
• Hospital and theatre fees
• Implant costs — standard implants are generally covered by funds; a custom implant needs ex-gratia approval
Each component is itemised so you can see what is and isn’t covered by your fund — and what you may owe out of pocket.
This page does not constitute a fee quotation. Costs and health-fund coverage vary by individual circumstance and are confirmed individually in writing before surgery. This page has been written in line with the Ahpra Guidelines for advertising a regulated health service.
FOR REFERRERS
SUITABLE FOR ROUTINE REFERRAL
COMPLEX / SPECIALIST REFERRAL
PLEASE INCLUDE
• Weight-bearing X‑rays of both ankles and feet, with Saltzman (hindfoot alignment) views
• CT if available — essential for revision and deformity cases
• EOS or long-leg standing alignment films where limb alignment is in question (Macquarie Medical Imaging at Macquarie University Hospital, or PRP Imaging at Norwest Private Hospital)
• Mechanism and date of any prior injury
• Previous operative notes and implant details, if relevant
• Comorbidities — diabetes, smoking, vascular disease
• Functional limitations and patient goals
SYDNEY ADVANCED ORTHOPAEDICS · (02) 8882 9011 · MACQUARIE · NORWEST · EAST SYDNEY
LIMB RECONSTRUCTION SERVICE NSW · (02) 9602 1113 · CAMPBELLTOWN
COMMON QUESTIONS
RELATED
BEGIN
CALL THE ROOMS
MACQUARIE · NORWEST · EAST SYDNEY
CAMPBELLTOWN
This page provides general information about total ankle replacement and is not a substitute for individual medical advice. Surgery carries risks; outcomes vary between patients. Total ankle replacement and ankle fusion are both valid operations, selected based on individual case suitability. Custom implant procedures are performed in selected cases only. Diagrams are schematic and illustrative only. Advertising on this site complies with the AHPRA Guidelines for advertising a regulated health service.



